This establishment's wings and pizza selection is exceptional, and highly favored by patrons. Mike, the owner, and his team consistently deliver outstanding culinary results. I wholeheartedly recommend their services. Sincerely, "Wing Girl"

We ordered food from here yesterday and did a pick-up order. They had a special with pizza, wings, and ribs. We were not disappointed. Everything was absolutely delicious. If I could, I would give it all a hundred stars. The pizza was great, and the wings and ribs were so tender. The sauce was perfect. You have got to try this place. We can't wait to go back!!!

We had the ribs tonight, they were amazing! Fall off the bone with a delicious homemade BBQ sauce. I also got the baked beans n fries. Fries r jo jo's (delish) and the baked beans r the best. We Will be returning !!!

Wow. Was in the mood for ribs and remembered Geppettos supposedly had some pretty good ones. What I received were the best rack of ribs I've ever had in my life. Seriously these were amazing. Couldn't have been better.

Hands down one of my the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Wings were great too. Highly recommended!!!

First time customer here and I am sold!! I throughly enjoyed every bite especially the pizza! It tasted really really good!

This place has been consistent as long I can remember, one of the best Hawaiian pizza I ever had ( I never get it anywhere else because I know nobody can even come close to it) the ribs are tender melt in your mouth service is hit or miss but that's cuz they are real people working and sometimes they might have a bad day

TL;DR: Josh says this is the premier carry out restaurant in Northeast Ohio. Great food prepared by even better people, and a local business you can feel good about patronizing. Tell them Josh sent you, they WILL know who you're talking about! If you've got the time and desire to read more, I'm about to preach. This is the only review on my Google account. I only have a Google account because my phone necessitates it. This is the one place I can think of that's worth my time and effort to promote. I've been ordering carry out from Middleburg Heights Geppettos for about 20 years. When I lived in Middleburg, they were a bi-weekly indulgence. I don't live in range to get it quite as often these days but I drive by on the way home from work, so if the timing is right, I give them a shout. Whether it's been a week or six months, when I call I'm greeted with joy from a team that's had a genuinely shocking lack of turnover over the years. In a business segment that churns through employees like butter, the staff retention combined with the truly pleasant interactions every time tells me that this is a good place to work. It also means consistency. One of the reasons that national chains succeed over local joints is because you can typically trust that if you got something you liked, it will be the same the next time. But because of the staff longevity on offer here, you get the quality of a local restaurant with the consistency of a chain. I know exactly what my half slab rib meal is going to taste like, every time. I have dined all over Northeast Ohio, with an eye towards places like this, pizza, wings, ribs. Geppetto's is the king of NEO, and the Middleburg Heights location is one you can feel especially good about patronizing. Support an incredible local business and let Geppetto's take care of your dinner tonight. I'm willing to bet the first time won't be the last time. And like I said, tell 'em Josh sent you!